Bob Dylan’s Old, Weird Americana



By Brian Wise.

Shadows In The Night might immediately invite you to ask why Bob Dylan has bothered to record an album of songs recorded by Frank Sinatra but we would be better served to ask why not?

Of course, Dylan’s first two albums, now more than half a century ago, were replete with covers and over the past two decades he has been moving further away from the mainstream of American music onto the back roads and dusty tracks of its past.

In 1992 and 1993, in the midst of a writer’s block, he released Good As I Been To You and World Gone Wrong, two highly under-rated albums of mainly obscure folk and songs. The former album, Dylan’s first solely acoustic album in nearly three decades resulted in a magnificent version of ‘Jim Jones,’ one of the best things he has ever done. (Old Crow Medicine Show also do a spectacular live rendition based on Dylan’s reading of the song).

The recently released Basement Tapes Complete shows Dylan’s fascination with old songs and just a few years after those recording sessions he released Self Portrait, packed with covers. Then there was the bizarre Christmas In The Heart five years ago with its collection of catarrhal interpretations that gave a completely new (and sometimes frightening) meaning to the Christmas album concept.

If you needed any more evidence of Dylan’s immersion in the past then you only need to listen to episodes of his radio show to appreciate his knowledge and affection for this old-timey music.

So Shadows In The Night does not necessarily signify something that Dylan has not done before – weird maybe but not new. It might seem a strange move after there has been such a flood of similar albums in the past decade, especially Rod Stewart’s series of Great American Songbook albums, all of which went gold or platinum. Even Paul McCartney had his turn with the appallingly titled Kisses On The Bottom.

It seems that when any singer is in doubt about what to do, or the well has dried up then they turn to the so-called ‘standards’ to pay the rent. These albums sell in the millions but mostly do little to enhance the songs or introduce audiences to overlooked material. The recent exception to this was Diana Krall’s excellent T. Bone Burnett produced album Glad Rag Doll (2012) with a terrific song selection and superb interpretations. But even Krall has chosen a safer and much less interesting route with her new album Wallflower (titled after and, ironically perhaps, containing the Dylan song).

Shadows In The Night, on the other hand, is anything but a safe bet for Dylan with its collection of mainly obscure songs (apart perhaps from Rodgers & Hammerstein’s ‘Some Enchanted Evening,’ Irving Berlin’s ‘What’ll I Do’ and ‘That Lucky Old Sun,’ written by Haven Gillespie and Beasley Smith in 1949) that ensure it will receive almost no commercial radio airplay at all (which is possibly why Columbia has sent out 50,000 free copies to members of the American Association of Retired Persons!).

Ironically, the man partly responsible for the rise of the singer-songwriter – where everyone thinks they have to sing their own songs – has gone back to interpreting the songs of others. He first made his mark in an era when it was rare for singers to also be composers and the New York Brill Building housed a host of the greatest pop songwriters of all time. Now Dylan returns to the past – as he has done so many times in his career – and pays homage to an era in which there were a lot of great songwriters.

Of course, Dylan’s voice has been pilloried by critics for the past few years – apart from his 2014 concerts that received rave reviews for what appeared to be rejuvenated vocals. Yet in 2011 Dylan appeared at The White House and sang with clarity and feeling – it seems he can turn it on and off.

If you saw him at one of the shows where his lyrics were indecipherable you might not be scampering out to buy this new album but do not rush to judgement. (In fact, when you hear it you might want your money back on the concert tickets!)

Believe it or not, Dylan is singing better on Shadows In The Night Dylan than he has for many years, perhaps decades. As Leonard Cohen and his band have superbly proved to us in concert recently, you do not have to be loud to be heard.

The songs on this album were designed for the singer to be close to the microphone, to caress the lyrics rather than belt them out and Dylan does this to wonderful effect. It is as if he invests his 73 years into each song and he is now the perfect age to capture their ambience. It is an astonishing performance. The sound is fantastic!

Unlike similar albums by many other performers, Dylan inhabits the songs until you think they could indeed be his own. This is homage in its purest form. Michael Bublé has made a fortune imitating Frank Sinatra but he will never sound this convincing!

Shadows In The Night features Dylan’s road-hardened touring band led by bassist Tony Garnier with some beautiful pedal steel guitar from Donnie Heron, guitars from Stu Kimball and Charlie Sexton and very tasteful and almost minimal drumming from George Receli. This formidable ensemble, which has been with Dylan for some years now, is augmented by a six-piece horn section.

Shadows In Night is all about mood – and here it is predominantly melancholy, echoing the feeling evoked on one of Dylan’s greatest modern songs, ‘Not Dark Yet’ (from 1997’s Time Out Of Mind). In many ways this is one of Dylan’s most focused albums in decades – which doesn’t mean it is one of his best.

Here almost all of the songs tell stories of romance: love (‘Some Enchanted Evening’), unrequited love (‘I’m A Fool To Want To Want You,’ ‘Full Moon and Empty Arms’) and faded love (‘The Night We Called It A Day,’ Irving Berlin’s ‘What’ll I Do,’ ’Autumn Leaves’); regret (‘Why Try To Change Me Now’); and, finally, mortality (‘That Lucky old Sun’).

Obviously, an album of Sinatra-style ballads is hardly a commercial move but you suspect that Dylan neither intended it to be so nor cared much anyway. At this stage of his life he proves once again that he can do whatever he wants to do.

The thing to keep in mind is that every time Dylan has retreated to the past or gone off on a tangent he has then produced something of greatness. Let’s hope that is the case now.

Brian Wise

Brian Wise was the Editor of Addicted To Noise‘s Australian site from 1997 – 2002. The site won two ONYA Awards as Best Online Music Magazine in 1999 & 2000. He has also been Editor since its reincarnation in 2013. He also presents the weekly music interview program Off The Record on 102.7 Triple R-FM ( in Melbourne. It is networked to 45+ stations across Australia on the Community Radio Network and is a four-time winner of the Best Music Program Award from the Community Broadcasting Association of Australia. In 2012, it was nominated as a finalist in the Excellence in Music Programming category. Brian was also the Founding Editor & Publisher of Rhythms Magazine and is now its Senior Contributing Editor.

Subscribe to our mailing list!